Most, if not all of us have come close to throwing the creative towel at one point or another during our career or studies. When our dreams fail to neatly fall into place once we wake up, should we heed our inner voice and pack it all in?
In one such case, a college senior posted a project for a review, not expecting the lukewarm reception it received. Although the critiques weren't necessarily cutting, the responses were enough for the student to seriously reconsider her major.
The fact of the matter is, if you don't have a paying design gig or haven't been exposed to real work in some way (as an intern for example), it doesn't matter if you're valedictorian in your class, you're still "starting out" in this business. Even then, professionals still receive their fair share of "surprise" critiques now and again.
Designers naturally tend to put out a bit of themselves into every piece they create—it's what defines our individual style. However, those outside the field, whom we call "clients" and toil to satisfy seldom appreciate that, nor really care so long as they're happy with the end results. More often than not, their less constructive observations are partially motivated by two factors: time and getting the most out of their investment.
As unpleasant as it may be, don't become too unraveled from a negative forum critique. If you do then perhaps you should question whether this business is right for you. It won't get any easier once you enter the market. I've seen women AND men reduced to tears when their talent was openly challenged. This industry can be as merciless as it is rewarding—you need to develop some thick skin and learn to not only roll with the punches, but glean the constructive critiques from the negative to improve and grow.
That said, I still had to applaud the original poster for putting her project up for scrutiny in a public forum. Rather than be satisfied with only her school's resources, she (perhaps unwittingly) took the direction of her career into her own hands to improve upon her skills. She stepped outside of the bubble—quite admirable. Many folks are afraid to publically subject themselves to any negative feedback and become defensive when they do. That sort of trepidation will more than likely stunt their growth in the long run. I can guarantee that even though the comments were an eye opener for this student, if she doesn't give up she won't regret her decision.
University design programs not with standing, there are plenty of completely self-taught designers who's work kick ass because they took matters into their own hands, supplemented their studies by buying books on various design principles, or joined respected creative forums for guidance and improvement, among other things. They took action.
You're likely going to discover on your own, should you remain in this biz, that design is a life-long learning process. We ALL continue to be students—our goal is to always continue to improve our game, whether it's on our own or through other means. Perhaps, camaraderie aside, that's why we join forums to begin with.
Overall, I think it's safe to say that the forum critiques—whether they are curt or coddling—are generally meant in the spirit of helping one to learn, grow and improve. However the reality is that in this alpha driven industry, with so many deadlines and big money clients breathing down your neck, you will likely run into a situation where the responses will reflect the same caliber of harsh observations one is subjected to in the professional arena. The trick is to keep an open mind, read between the lines, work to apply the helpful suggestions and ditch the rest.
If, after all is said and done, you still feel like quitting after a lackluster review or three instead of re-applying yourself, then perhaps you do need to rethink your career path after all.
The fact of the matter is, if you don't have a paying design gig or haven't been exposed to real work in some way (as an intern for example), it doesn't matter if you're valedictorian in your class, you're still "starting out" in this business. Even then, professionals still receive their fair share of "surprise" critiques now and again.
Designers naturally tend to put out a bit of themselves into every piece they create—it's what defines our individual style. However, those outside the field, whom we call "clients" and toil to satisfy seldom appreciate that, nor really care so long as they're happy with the end results. More often than not, their less constructive observations are partially motivated by two factors: time and getting the most out of their investment.
As unpleasant as it may be, don't become too unraveled from a negative forum critique. If you do then perhaps you should question whether this business is right for you. It won't get any easier once you enter the market. I've seen women AND men reduced to tears when their talent was openly challenged. This industry can be as merciless as it is rewarding—you need to develop some thick skin and learn to not only roll with the punches, but glean the constructive critiques from the negative to improve and grow.
That said, I still had to applaud the original poster for putting her project up for scrutiny in a public forum. Rather than be satisfied with only her school's resources, she (perhaps unwittingly) took the direction of her career into her own hands to improve upon her skills. She stepped outside of the bubble—quite admirable. Many folks are afraid to publically subject themselves to any negative feedback and become defensive when they do. That sort of trepidation will more than likely stunt their growth in the long run. I can guarantee that even though the comments were an eye opener for this student, if she doesn't give up she won't regret her decision.
University design programs not with standing, there are plenty of completely self-taught designers who's work kick ass because they took matters into their own hands, supplemented their studies by buying books on various design principles, or joined respected creative forums for guidance and improvement, among other things. They took action.
You're likely going to discover on your own, should you remain in this biz, that design is a life-long learning process. We ALL continue to be students—our goal is to always continue to improve our game, whether it's on our own or through other means. Perhaps, camaraderie aside, that's why we join forums to begin with.
Overall, I think it's safe to say that the forum critiques—whether they are curt or coddling—are generally meant in the spirit of helping one to learn, grow and improve. However the reality is that in this alpha driven industry, with so many deadlines and big money clients breathing down your neck, you will likely run into a situation where the responses will reflect the same caliber of harsh observations one is subjected to in the professional arena. The trick is to keep an open mind, read between the lines, work to apply the helpful suggestions and ditch the rest.
If, after all is said and done, you still feel like quitting after a lackluster review or three instead of re-applying yourself, then perhaps you do need to rethink your career path after all.
